Who has the most PTSD?

Katie · Post by **Katie** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 8:14 am

A penny for your thoughts. (I added Mutou because I think the fact that he's so sad all the time means he mighta had a hard life)

Comrade · Post by **Comrade** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 8:34 am

What's PTSD?

Kyler Thatch · Post by **Kyler Thatch** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 9:40 am

It stands for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. Basically an irrational fear of something related to some kind of psychological trauma a person had in the past.

Like, if I got in a car accident and almost died, I might be afraid to get in a car again for a while.

Oddball · Post by **Oddball** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 11:39 am

Hanako seems to be the only one that has this, unless you want to count Kenji's fear of phones. Otherwise he's just a crackpot.

bhtooefr · Post by **bhtooefr** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 12:26 pm

Wait, a Katie poll that isn't batshit insane? (Well, OK, the Mutou option is out of nowhere.)

We don't see enough about Sae to know whether she suffers from PTSD.

If Hisao suffers from PTSD, it's pretty minor.

That leaves Kenji, Emi, and Hanako.

Emi can function despite her PTSD. (That said, her PTSD forms the core conflict of her route.)

Kenji's problems aren't just PTSD.

Hanako... now she's got industrial-strength PTSD.

Antonymous · Post by **Antonymous** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 1:55 pm

Oddball wrote:Hanako seems to be the only one that has this, unless you want to count Kenji's fear of phones. Otherwise he's just a crackpot.

Kenji's all fucked up because he thinks Yuuko stole his soul through his dick because he got tired after sex.

edit: I instinctively voted Hanako, but now that I think about it, Kenji got way more fucked up. Hanako, at some level, still remained a functioning member of society. Kenji literally went crazy and actually fucking murdered someone.

Comrade · Post by **Comrade** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 2:04 pm

Antonymous wrote:
Oddball wrote:Hanako seems to be the only one that has this, unless you want to count Kenji's fear of phones. Otherwise he's just a crackpot.
Kenji's all fucked up because he thinks Yuuko stole his soul through his dick because he got tired after sex.

edit: I instinctively voted Hanako, but now that I think about it, Kenji got way more fucked up. Hanako, at some level, still remained a functioning member of society. Kenji literally went crazy and actually fucking murdered someone.

Murdered? Who?
Besides, Kenji is very functional. He made all these interesting websites with graphs...

Oddball · Post by **Oddball** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 3:09 pm

Kenji is perfectly capable of interacting with others, including females. He just chooses not to.

He helps out with the signs for the class project doesn't he?

Hanako on the other hand needs somebody to be there for her otherwise she's going to panic and flee when faced with strangers or just too many people in general.

Steinherz · Post by **Steinherz** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 3:48 pm

Hanako. Definitely Hanako.
That Mutou option is way out from left-field XD

Comrade wrote:
Antonymous wrote:actually fucking murdered someone.
Murdered? Who?
Besides, Kenji is very functional. He made all these interesting websites with graphs...

Kenji threw Hisao off the roof. In one route he straight up said he'd do that to make it look like an accident.

Oddball wrote:Hanako on the other hand needs somebody to be there for her otherwise she's going to panic and flee when faced with strangers or just too many people in general.

Wait, didn't Hanako function fine in groups when she's not the focus of the group's attention?

Comrade · Post by **Comrade** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 4:00 pm

That wasn't murder it was mercy killing, Kenji knew Hisao didn't got together with any of the girls amd decided death was the better option for him

Sea · Post by **Sea** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 4:15 pm

How is there any other choice but Hanako?
Other characters have some PTSD, but Hanako takes the cake.

Antonymous · Post by **Antonymous** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 4:16 pm

I'd argue as to why Kenji would be far worse off in terms of employment, but that's not the point. The point is that Hanako has suffered a great deal of PTSD, but unlike Kenji, it didn't turn her into a delusional maniac who will murder someone at the slightest provocation. The only reason why it looks like Hanako's is more severe is because Kenji's ordeal is hilarious.

Dr. Casey · Post by **Dr. Casey** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 6:27 pm

Comrade wrote:That wasn't murder it was mercy killing, Kenji knew Hisao didn't got together with any of the girls amd decided death was the better option for him

Haha, what.

I can't tell if this post is serious or not, but it's hilarious either way. I didn't have a girlfriend at 18 either, but I'm quite glad that nobody decided that it was for my own good to put me down.

ShadeHaven · Post by **ShadeHaven** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 6:30 pm

I'd say Hanako, but Emi would be a close second. Sure she can still function, but they've both lost family members and are reminded of that by their own disabilities.

bhtooefr · Post by **bhtooefr** » Mon Nov 04, 2013 6:52 pm

Kenji's PTSD is a rather minor part of what's wrong with him, though. Subtract the PTSD, and he'd still be paranoid and delusional, just slightly less so, and more in general than focused on feminists. Subtract the paranoid delusions, and he'd be a mostly normal misogynist, even with the PTSD. (Never mind that the PTSD only occurred because of the paranoid delusions.)

And, Hanako lost so much more than her family - the fact that she lost positive human interaction after the fire is, apparently, a far more severe source of PTSD for her. Emi didn't have any of that - she only lost one parent, she didn't lose the ability to have positive human interaction, and she didn't even lose her other passion, running.

Katawa Shoujo Forums