Shizune, good ending. Good memories. After dying trying to take on Emi route, then doing Emi the right way, I played Shizune's bad ending... a week ago. It hurts me.
Having cheated on Shizune with Misha did a number on me. While I was planning to do the Hanako route now, I am redoing the Shizune good ending.
While I agree (so far) Shizune's route is bad, I am attracted to Shizune herself. I guess that is why it hurts me so much to see the bad ending. I don't know what it is, but Shizune is just the girl I like. For the other ones, Emi/Rin are a light turnoff, I am judgemental enough to annoy myself with the missing limbs

However, I played Emi because she also seemed like a nice girl personality-wise, and I did not regret it. Rin, even though I did not have much time with her yet, is annoying to me. Sulky behavior and so. While Hanako seems like a nice route to me, I am turned off by her nervousness a bit, still. I am annoyed by inconfidence irl too, so yeah. Lilly is too polite for me. Not to mention she is the enemy of Shizune

I think she will be last.