Katawa Shoujo Forums

dewelar wrote:"Heh...not "trouble" exactly, but definitely girl-related – specifically, spitting-out-how-I-feel-about-a-girl-related." Yoshi sighs, his face pointed toward the ceiling. "I'm just trying to find the right way to approach her. Since my advice worked so well for you with Satou, I suppose I could try the direct approach myself...although since the two are pretty far apart personality-wise, maybe not."

OK, there's about three girls I'm thinking that could refer to, depending on what personality aspects he's referring to. Unless this is a red herring.

One of them, he'd be working with closely, and isn't story relevant. (Although, Shizune getting laid might mellow her out a bit when Lilly returns...)

The other two... A CHALLENGER APPEARS?

Edit: Actually, now that I reread that passage... Yeah, a challenger appears. For Hanako. I think. Both Shizune and Emi would welcome the direct approach pretty obviously, whereas Hanako welcoming it would not be obvious.

Edit 2: Wait a second...

dewelar wrote:"Okay, these two girls, they're both Yamaku students, right?"

"Yeah," I say, not sure why that would matter.

"Okay, good," he says with an odd tone in his voice. The rest of what Yoshi says comes out in a bit of a rush. "That's good."

It's not a student... And he's also closely working with someone who the direct approach doesn't work with that well... And she also has a fanon history of dating Yamaku students...

My first thought was that another safety net was unfolding for Hanako - especially since in this chapter he seemed to be leaning towards Emi pretty obviously - but the thing about the students was a nice catch...
Only minor nitpick is the time-skip. That one could use some visual pointing out.

Mirage_GSM wrote:Only minor nitpick is the time-skip. That one could use some visual pointing out.

You're talking about the one from the end of the conversation with Yoshi to the next morning, I presume. Yeah, I couldn't come up with something to fill in that was satisfying to me, so I thought it was reasonable to leave it as it is. I can always ponder and fill it in later if I come up with something (wouldn't be the first time I've done it ).

Mirage_GSM wrote:especially since in this chapter he seemed to be leaning towards Emi pretty obviously

But he flip-flops more than John Kerry was accused of in the 2004 US presidential elections.

Next chapter will probably reverse that, if dewelar keeps things up the way he has been.

This chapter made me realize how much of a mentor figure Nurse becomes in this fic.

I mean, he's always important in canon, but in a lot of paths he kind of fades out, and even in Emi's route he doesn't really get too personal with Hisao. But in this fic he's like Hisao's Qui-Gon.

I like it, I just think it's interesting. And it makes me think more closely about the very contrary way I handle him in my own story.

Also, I'm not going to lie. I'm really hoping you're going to swerve us all and have Hisao fall in love with a total dark horse candidate like Miss Miyagi.

bhtooefr wrote:But he flip-flops more than John Kerry was accused of in the 2004 US presidential elections.

You do realize there could be people browsing these forums who were born after that reference was topical, right?

Leaty wrote:This chapter made me realize how much of a mentor figure Nurse becomes in this fic.

I mean, he's always important in canon, but in a lot of paths he kind of fades out, and even in Emi's route he doesn't really get too personal with Hisao. But in this fic he's like Hisao's Qui-Gon.

You know...when I read my chapters to my friend, I'd been reading Nurse in a George Takei-ish voice. I'm now totally switching to Liam Neeson .

Also, I'm not going to lie. I'm really hoping you're going to swerve us all and have Hisao fall in love with a total dark horse candidate like Miss Miyagi.

*takes notes*

Leaty wrote:

bhtooefr wrote:But he flip-flops more than John Kerry was accused of in the 2004 US presidential elections.

You do realize there could be people browsing these forums who were born after that reference was topical, right?

I would hope there's not 9 year olds browsing these forums! (But, I wouldn't be surprised if there are people on here who were too young to get that reference...)

And, Nurse will always have Zapp Brannigan's voice in my head.

Edit: If we're tossing out dark horse candidates... Calling it now. Naomi x Natsume x Hisao OT3. You heard it here first, folks. No, that makes no sense. And I'm not even sure if Naomi and Natsume are a thing in this story.

bhtooefr wrote:And, Nurse will always have Zapp Brannigan's voice in my head.

Emi, I've made it with your mother. Inform the men.

In all seriousness, Hisao seems as unsure of himself as ever in this chapter. You write his state of mind well, but god it is frustrating to read sometimes. So well done? I guess that's what I'm trying to say.

But seriously, Hisao. Just man the fuck up and get with Meiko already.

dewelar wrote:
You know...when I read my chapters to my friend, I'd been reading Nurse in a George Takei-ish voice. I'm now totally switching to Liam Neeson .

I always imagined that kinda voice too. For some reason it seems to fit. Then again I also gave Mutuo a similar voice, so I'm probably just not very creative in the voices I give people.

AntonSlavik020 wrote:

dewelar wrote:
You know...when I read my chapters to my friend, I'd been reading Nurse in a George Takei-ish voice. I'm now totally switching to Liam Neeson .

I always imagined that kinda voice too. For some reason it seems to fit. Then again I also gave Mutuo a similar voice, so I'm probably just not very creative in the voices I give people.

To me, Mutuo will always be Batman.

In my head, Mutou is voiced by JK Simmons.

Leaty wrote:In my head, Mutou is voiced by JK Simmons.

AKA Cave Johnson? That is awesome.

AntonSlavik020 wrote:

Leaty wrote:In my head, Mutou is voiced by JK Simmons.

AKA Cave Johnson? That is awesome.

AKA J. Jonah Jameson, you mean.

forgetmenot wrote:

AntonSlavik020 wrote:

Leaty wrote:In my head, Mutou is voiced by JK Simmons.

AKA Cave Johnson? That is awesome.

AKA J. Jonah Jameson, you mean.

Yeah, him too. Man that guy plays a lot of awesome roles.

forgetmenot wrote:

bhtooefr wrote: But seriously, Hisao. Just man the fuck up and get with Meiko already.

I like the way you think

Again, great chapter! I don't even know who to cheer for to be completely honest.. but I guess that's what you're going for