Katawa Shoujo Forums

Brogurt wrote:

Aura wrote: What the sex scenes get replaced with is not final I guess, but we are currently not planning to write some replacement scenes that contain the same events, except without the sex. If you don't read them you'll miss whatever's in them.

This, coupled with your statement from the Fakku Q&A that each path will have multiple h-scenes, makes me feel like those of us who don't want hentai with our story will be getting a gutted version of the game. And I don't like that feel.

You can skip the sex scenes in A Song of Ice and Fire if you want. Just don't complain when you miss all the plot points that are related to those sex scenes.

Suriko wrote:you aren't going to find the equivalent of Harry beating Voldemort happening during sex.

Boy, that would sure change the audience for those books…

to totally change the context of the potter books, it only takes switching a d with a g in a single word

heres a hint...

something silvery white, something enormous, erupted from the end of harry's wanG (Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, time-traveling harrys patronus)

and a bunch more :
"Get - off - me!' Harry gasped. For a few seconds they struggled, Harry pulling at his uncles sausage-like fingers with his left hand, his right maintaining a firm grip on his raised wand" (Prisoner of Azkaban) (remember... d = g)
"Now don't forget that nice wrist movement we've been practising" (Philosper's Stone)
"My own brother Aberforth was prosecuted for practising inapropiate charms on a goat" (Goblet Of Fire)
"Does he still think I entered myself?" (Goblet Of Fire)
"...don't fufill their requiremnts .. half an inch" (Chamber Of Secrets)
"Can I see Uranus too, Lavender?" (Prisioner Of Azkaban)
"Tell me what Malfoy's doing inside you" (Half-Blood Prince)
"Harry stuffed his wand hastily back into his jeans and tried to look innocent." (OOtP)

and the piece da resistance! : http://www.vincentchow.net/images/harry-gay.jpg

My favorite HP quote is from book 5, near the beginning, when Harry asks Dudley, "What do you mean, I'm not brave in bed?"

>This is now a Harry Potter topic
Seriously guys?

Anyway, I guess I can only hope that the devs manage to write the stories well enough that things fit coherently together without the boning. But that shouldn't be hard, right? Right? ;_;

Shades of gray wrote:to totally change the context of the potter books, it only takes switching a d with a g in a single word

I couldn't leave without saying thanks for this. I didn't care much for HP but I never... saw all those references like that!

Brogurt, are you saying you are so adverse to the h-scenes that you'll choose to play without them regardless?

I was (am) actually very naive and didn't even realise KS was a eroge until visting the blog. I found out about the game when it was mentioned in a best of vn review thing. Scanning the website I completely missed the single sentence where it said this game will contain mature content - I just downloaded it based on the screenshots and what I briefly read in the review. There isn't even any mention of it in the manuel, which I did read beforehand to get an idea of what I was about to play.

So after completing it and visting the blog I read Could Be So Much More and went through the same process of changing my perspective as Ellume. I'm quite looking forward to the whole game, still much more for the story, but also for the sensitive and creative portrayal of sex that I have little doubt the devs can pull off.

As an aside, I didn't realise that there would be multiple scenes with each girl! What a surprise that would have been...

Personally I would be a little disappointed if there is no sex in the game. I mean, what about the vision?!?

Every time some one comes up and says 'pleaz no p0rn', a little devil dies.

griffon8 wrote:

Suriko wrote:you aren't going to find the equivalent of Harry beating Voldemort happening during sex.

Boy, that would sure change the audience for those books…

I very much doubt it.

I think it would take some extreme finesse to put any important dialogue into a sex scene and not have it come off as completely ridiculous.

That said, it would be amazing. And in Rin's case, entirely fitting to the character.

Imagine if every huge twist in the story occurred during a single sex scene; massive revelations pouring out, one after the other, in a torrent of storytelling genius mixed with horrendous in-world timing.

Hisao and Hanako lie together under the stars, wrapped in their picnic blanket, and begin making sweet love... only for Rin to come bounding up with horrible news, Emi's been shot by Kenji! Suddenly, Lilly lands right in the middle of this jarring scene - literally, after parachuting from a crashing, burning plane piloted by none other than the school nurse, who is actually a communist spy who has been lacing the students' medication with mind-control devices! By the end of the whole ordeal, Hisao is on a quest with his rag-tag team of die-hard cripple girls to destroy the re-surging Communist Bloc and take down zombie Stalin before his own mind becomes another slave to the Red Legions. Sure hope you didn't skip THAT sex scene, girls and boys, or you're going to be wondering where the FUCK that came from.

And yes, Hisao and Hanako were still doing it the whole time.

Limbless wrote:And yes, Hisao and Hanako were still doing it the whole time.

Of course, when were they given any good reason to stop?

I've yet to read a VN where something important happened during a sex scene. The only thing the first scene between the protagonist and one of the females does is make the protagonist realize that he likes the female, and he usually wants a better relationship with her afterwards. The other scenes just reinforce the protagonist's feelings for the female character. I would shocked if some unexpected plot did occur during a sex scene, it would make for a nice change of pace.

Nothing unexpected ever happens during sex scenes. Well, except for

Goldilurks wrote:

Limbless wrote:And yes, Hisao and Hanako were still doing it the whole time.

Of course, when were they given any good reason to stop?

Cue futa-Misha.

HeMeido wrote:

Brogurt wrote:

Aura wrote: What the sex scenes get replaced with is not final I guess, but we are currently not planning to write some replacement scenes that contain the same events, except without the sex. If you don't read them you'll miss whatever's in them.

This, coupled with your statement from the Fakku Q&A that each path will have multiple h-scenes, makes me feel like those of us who don't want hentai with our story will be getting a gutted version of the game. And I don't like that feel.

You can skip the sex scenes in A Song of Ice and Fire if you want. Just don't complain when you miss all the plot points that are related to those sex scenes.

I'll take the sex for what it's worth. fap fap fap fap okay I'll stop now...

Actionman3457 wrote:I've yet to read a VN where something important happened during a sex scene.

Shuffle! (by Navel), Primula's route, 2nd sex scene....

There will be enough porn made of these characters one way or another. Just look at the fan art. Oh god, look at the fan art.