Katawa Shoujo Forums

Personally something tells me hanako but then again we see at the end of act 1 she becomes very trusting of him so iit could go either way tho i think it will be more fun if it turns into a wild goose chase or more simply put like if you where a dog and started chaseing your on tail.

but still hard to determin

Just got a freaky thought when hisao and lily start to well you get the point. and he has a heart attack during they're ''fun time'' she wouldnt know untill he goes limp prolly would be freaking funny as a bad end

^ Freaky.
Nah, not gonna happen. Lilly noticed when Hisao had an attack while they were walking together. She would definitely notice it at direct contact.

OneMore wrote:^ Freaky.
Nah, not gonna happen. Lilly noticed when Hisao had an attack while they were walking together. She would definitely notice it at direct contact.

She's blind right, she got super senses!
Shes be like: Your heart has speed up, I can feel and hear it!

Lilly: Ninja.

Priest wrote:Just got a freaky thought when hisao and lily start to well you get the point. and he has a heart attack during they're ''fun time'' she wouldnt know untill he goes limp prolly would be freaking funny as a bad end

It's not like the first hint that a person has died in that situation comes from a visual stimulus...

I don't care

Disclaimer: I'm married to a woman who has severe body image issues. Part of that includes severe scarring, so my perspective on Hanako is somewhat skewed.

If you're going purely by how long in the narrative it will be before an ero scene, that's going to depend on a lot of different factors that are nearly impossible to ascertain. As for actual progression in a relationship, here's how I see it working:



Hanako - I think she would be a lot 'easier' than most. Being absorbed with books all the time, Hanako is going to be prone to fits of fantasy involving Hisao, and once her barriers come down, it's going to be a relatively short jump to intercourse. As soon as she is convinced that Hisao doesn't care about her body issues, she will likely be open to it. The hard part about intercourse with a girl like Hanako isn't getting HER interested, it's finding a guy who can legitimately look beyond her barriers convincingly.

That said, I suspect the story will likely focus on Hisao getting her to lower those barriers, and thus it's still not going to happen early in the narrative.


Shizune - While it's going to hinge on what Shizune's goals are, I don't easily foresee her jumping straight into the sack by any means - her outward assertiveness is very likely to be a front.

Shizune is deaf and mute, but that doesn't mean she's incapable of vocalizing, and in real life, deaf mutes can have issues as a result; depending on just how sensitive she is underneath the shell, she might be averse to actually having sex due to the embarrassment of the sounds she might make during intercourse. I actually hope this becomes part of the conflict in Shizune's path.


Lilly - Probably the hardest call for me. Lilly, more than any of the other girls, feels like she's constantly maintaining a mask, possibly due to her upbringing, and so I never really felt I had a strong grasp on the real her.

In any case, I would guess her scenes to be the most awkward, unless she has past experience.


Rin - I see Rin as being relatively disinterested in keeping sex a 'pure' act, in the sense that it should be withheld and kept as a 'special' thing, but I could see it going both ways between not really being interested in sex, or being curious about sex, which brings a wide spectrum of possibilities. In any case, I don't see her as being one who is strongly opposed to intercourse by any means if Hisao were to push it.


Emi - Probably the most conflicted; Act 1 constantly focuses on Emi's desires conflicting with Emi's concerns. This works well with my own interpretation. Personality-wise, I see Emi as the hormonally charged girl who really WANTS to go at it with Hisao, but who is tempered by her own desire not to hurt and/or kill Hisao via exertion.

As a result, I fully expect that Emi will be the dominant one in the intimate scenes, but that they're also going to be later in the timeline due to health concerns.


In order from 'easiest' to 'toughest' as far as how much personal effort it will take from Hisao to get anywhere, I suspect it will look like this:

Emi
Rin
Shizune -
Lilly
Hanako


As far as time from start to sex goes (real time, not narrative time), it will probably be more

Hanako
Rin
Shizune
Lilly
Emi

Calessa wrote:Disclaimer: I'm married to a woman who has severe body image issues. Part of that includes severe scarring, so my perspective on Hanako is somewhat skewed.

I appreciate that. You saved me the trouble of writing an exasperatingly long and poorly thought out wall of text telling you why I disagree.

Also, I can't help but think, after reading the following

Calessa wrote:Being absorbed with books all the time, Hanako is going to be prone to fits of fantasy involving Hisao

"Yes, I'm a virgin, but I've watched plenty of porn -I mean, read plenty of erotic novels before, so I'm pretty confident in my abilities."

Because she reads so many books, I've always seen Hanako as a romantic. Fantasies and book reading are great forms of escapism.

I loved reading when I was young. When I was 8 years old I read at least 4 books every month and many above the recommended readers age so when I was older (around 12-3 years old I think) and I started having more interest in sex I found my parents complete porn and erotics novel collection and read throught it too. There was a lot of informative material but also a lot of things that almost caused me a trauma from BDSM to rape XP MY point being that loving books can get you the knowledge of a sexual fiend at least on a theoretical level

Nowadays we have the internet and The Internet Is For Porn.

OneMore wrote:^ Freaky.
Nah, not gonna happen. Lilly noticed when Hisao had an attack while they were walking together. She would definitely notice it at direct contact.

d

yra guess your right but still funny as hell to think about

Yukimi wrote:I loved reading when I was young. When I was 8 years old I read at least 4 books every month and many above the recommended readers age so when I was older (around 12-3 years old I think) and I started having more interest in sex I found my parents complete porn and erotics novel collection and read throught it too. There was a lot of informative material but also a lot of things that almost caused me a trauma from BDSM to rape XP MY point being that loving books can get you the knowledge of a sexual fiend at least on a theoretical level

Nowadays we have the internet and The Internet Is For Porn.

I kinda agree i read alot of books too... not so many erotic ones but i agree alot of info is too be found in books. allso i personally think you cant call porno real sex since theres no emotion in it if you get what i am playing at

This topic is so amazingly popular, I'm surprised it is still going. I mean it seems obvious that for each character it can go either way, just depends on how you twist it.

Priest wrote:allso i personally think you cant call porno real sex since theres no emotion in it if you get what i am playing at

The way I see it, sex in porn is sex. Because what they're doing is sex. If you want sex with emotion, you could call that making love.

atat wrote:for each character it can go either way, just depends on how you twist it.

Hence why it's so popular/still going.

Personally, I reckon they all seem like they'd have reservations about actually having sex, if for different reasons.

Emi would probably be the most up for it, but she's so over-conscious of Hisao's condition that she probably wouldn't want to strain him.
Hanako is pretty likely to latch on to someone she trusts... well, not just likely, it's been shown. I reckon once Hisao was 'in' with her, he'd be 'in' her whenever he wanted to, but until then even looking at her is taboo.
Lilly... in reality, I couldn't see her having sex with anyone before marriage. She gives off the 'proper' vibe in that way.
Rin's an enigma, as always. Although, assuming she's a virgin, she would definitely want to do it 'just to see what it's like' at some point or other. Probably at an extremely inappropriate time. She probably wouldn't consider it 'special'.
Shizune's bound to have issues with becoming 'vulnerable' like during sex.

Misha, however, would do just about everyone in a heartbeat. Especially the teacher.

Yukimi wrote:Nowadays we have the internet and The Internet Is For Porn.

Fixed that for you.