Katawa Shoujo Forums

Or it's possible that she's just leading him on and not actually interested... in which case, she could be one of the more frustrating paths in the game, as winning her over in that case could be... difficult, to say the least.

A lot of this is open to interpretation... I feel like anyone other than Emi could go either way, and only her because I think her reaction would probably be the baseline, normal-teenage-girl reaction to compare the others to. What I said above (and I really should register eventually if I plan on continuing to post here, shouldn't I?) is my best guesses, but I'll be surprised if I'm not wrong about at least one. (Lilly I'm mostly certain I'm right about, but as far as Rin goes, anything could happen.)

I think Shizune has the potential to put out the earliest. I hesitate to say "easiest" because, honestly, when is anything easy when it comes to Shizune?

I didn't see a thread about this on pages one or two of the public discussion, and I figured anything older than that would earn the ire of many of my fellow forumgoers if I were to gravedig it, so I apologize if this has already been discussed, but:

Hanako - Most likely a virgin. I can see her coming as far as being rejected during foreplay due to her extensive scarring if she had dated a blind boy, but outside of that potential, her extreme self-consciousness leads me to believe that her cherry hasn't been popped.

Lilly - I don't want to think of her as a non-virgin, but it's definitely within the realm of possibility.

Rin - Most likely has had sex before. She seems like the sort of person who would be open to it. Not slutty, mind, but it seems like something that might be less of a big deal to her than others. Her supposed unattractiveness (as stated in the game) wouldn't even be a factor.

Shizune - It could easily go either way. She seems like the sort who would have had it on her own terms if she wanted it already.

Emi - Might be, might not. It certainly doesn't seem unreasonable, though I can see how her innocent personality might make it a hard pill to swallow if she'd done it.

And now for a couple non-path girls:

Yuuko - Probably at some point. I know she's a popular one for people to theorize as having been Kenji's ex.

Akira - Almost certainly. Just gives off that air of having done it. Not a slutty air, but just an experienced confidence.

Misha - Possibly. Wouldn't surprise me either way, to be honest.

This was already discussed somewhere but I don't remember in which thread.

Hanako is definately a virgin, everyone one else could go either way IMO.
But then there is usually an unwritten rule in VN thats says "Anyone who can be bagged, has most likely not been shagged"

Why does everyone care so much?

SirMax wrote:Why does everyone care so much?

Curiosity?

They are perverts?

They fear that they won't stand up too challenge?

They want to boost their own ego be guessing right about their lever of experience?

They might not enjoy that object of their affection is not so innocent/slutty as they hoped/feared?

Pick one... or all.

Hanako- Virgin. The developers would have to literally be gods to be able to come up with a storyline reason otherwise and it not be complete BS.
Lilly- She may have had one partner before, but it could go either way.
Shizune- I think she has. Knowing her, she may be the "bad experience" everyone says Kenji had.
Rin- No clue. I really don't know what to think here. Though if I had to guess one or the other I would say she had a boyfriend she got intimate with once.
Emi- I don't buy the "innocent little puppy dog" for a second, I think she's the most experienced of any of the ones that have a path.

Yuuko- I can see a romantic-comedy bit where she and a guy try to, but through her (and possibly his) clumsiness it doesn't go well. Whether they eventually manage to get to the deed is up in the air.
Akira- Yes. Several times. Not more than two or three partners (not at a time, probably several months apart, at least), but if her contrast with Lilly goes as deep as it's implied then yes, I'm almost certain she's well practiced.
Misha- Depends on how many deaf guys there are at the school. They're the only ones that could take her annoying volume. And she probably sleeps with one of them every night.

You guys forgot:
Molly - Multiple raep victim.

Two things:

1) Sorry I didn't just dig a little deeper, Devs, I just know that 'gravedigging' threads is considered a negative on most fora. Thanks for merging it to the appropriate thread, though!

2)

SirMax wrote:Why does everyone care so much?

I'm new here but I've seen this threaten to derail other threads so I figured I'd put in my two cents and create (or, as it turns out revive) a spot where people could get their thoughts off their chests without screwing up another thread.

Also, I've seen mostly extremes like "they're all innocent virgin angels except [insert least favorite girl here]" or "they're all sluts/into S&M/[insert other fetish here]", so I thought a realistic consideration was called for somewhat.

Obviously emi

Rin because she doesnt ever seem to give a shit about anything

Sid Vicious wrote:Rin because she doesnt ever seem to give a shit about anything

That might also make her the most difficult, though. Never can tell with Rin.

If the final product is supposed to span a course of 3 months, they'll all probably have their sex scene 2-3 months after their first encounter with Hisao, which would make them equal in terms of time.

As for who requires most effort, i can't say.

You thinking about this topic, I have come to the conclusion that for any of the girls it could be written either way, with in the current Act 1 style.

For Rin,
Put out way: For her, to be easy, it would be simply that she, as many people have already suggested, would not make a big deal about sex. Even if she were a virgin at the beginning of the story, I could still see her saying to Hisao when some how sex got brought up (maybe they are looking at something online and stumble across a porn ad, or looking at some art in a museum etc...) she would suggest it to 'see what it's like'.
For a more conservative approach: She might be friendly, and be open to talking about it, but not want to do it with just anybody, that she might need to 'feel' something first. When it feels right she would, and only then, things would have to be just perfect just like the mixing of the paint, the exact perfect mood.

For Lilly:
Put out way: Simple, I would say she would have some experience, and despite her refinement, she feel lust and passion like anyone else. Many shows are about 'refined woman' coming to terms with there own lust in a VERY aggressive way, and the passion Lilly shows when squaring off with Shizune, could be brought to Hisao and sex.
For a more conservative approach: Well she is refined, and would be 'old fashioned'. This does not really seem to need much explaining, as it is again a rather strait forward proposition.

For Shizune:
Put out way: She wants what she wants, and is confident in her goals and desires. If Hisao was her goal and desire she would do anything that she felt was with in that idea. Having sex with him would be a natural part of being a couple, and might be allowed by her as soon as it's declared 'we are a couple'. Of course, it would be when she felt like it probably. Then again, at this point she might prefer an aggressive Hisao that pulls her into the bedroom.
For a more conservative approach: Well it is well known that people often have different personalities in the sack then they do in the rest of their life. A person as aggressive in her life as Shizune, might be really with drawn when it comes to sex. She might even feel there is no place for it. She might be 'to busy' with life too, or perhaps her personality is an attempt to hide a lack of self confidence, so she over comps with a very aggressive stance.

For Emi:
Put out way: There is nothing special about how I see Emi being 'easy'. It might be that she's just more casual about sex, but I don't really think that she would see sex as a workout. She could be given the route of, 'I really like you, and want to do something for you, so let me make puppy dog eyes then we'll screw'. Being an athlete she might get a little more horny than others .
For the more conservative approach: She could use the excuse that she does not think Hisao could handle the activity yet, and wait for him to meet her health approval standards. Like wise one could also write it such that she is shy and meek. She may like to work out, but such activities, BLUSH!!!. All not that hard, and can fit with in her character.

Hanako:
Put out way: Well this would seem a little odd for some, but there is a simple and plausible way. For her to put out easy might be as simple as feeling a connection with a guy. Her lack of connection with other people, and guys for that matter, might make her very open to sex with the first guy she is friendly with. Once it is clear to her that he likes her, she might even jump to gun, and at what seems to the guy to not 'be the mood' she might be all over him.
For the more conservative approach: This is simple and strait forward, she's ultra-shy. Basically she is no matter how intimate she is with a guy, like she is with everyone, very reserved.

For non-paths characters:
Akira: It's easy to go either way, for the experienced mode, simple assume she has. Not so experienced? Maybe she's just to busy being modern girl to get any.

Misha: Easy to explain why she has not gotten any, nobody wants to. For that she has. well she probably only really had one past boy friend, and felt close to him, so they did.