Page 2 of 2
Re: Irreversible
Posted: Sun Apr 27, 2014 8:41 pm
by Liminaut
It's not a story about KS, it's a story about reading KS. As such, I thought is was an interesting and entertaining take on the matter. Experimental fiction is experimental.
Re: Irreversible
Posted: Sun Apr 27, 2014 11:07 pm
by Yukarin
my god this is the best concept ever
i like it very much! Question though, are you going to go for every girl's routes or no?
Re: Irreversible
Posted: Mon Apr 28, 2014 12:31 am
by Walshy12238
As mentioned by a few others before, I feel like it's mostly just a retelling of the story. Don't get me wrong, it has potential and I feel like you can make into something really cool, but for now it's just not hitting that.
I'll make sure to come back and read more when you update again, though. Best of luck!
Re: Irreversible
Posted: Mon Apr 28, 2014 4:19 am
by d2r
Yukarin wrote:my god this is the best concept ever
i like it very much! Question though, are you going to go for every girl's routes or no?
I don't think so - it would be repetitive.
Re: Irreversible
Posted: Mon Apr 28, 2014 10:36 am
by Blasphemy
I enjoyed this and actually made me think about how I may have experienced the game if I had approached it like that, that is if such a reverse version existed. I assume I probably wouldn't really have appreciated it much... I mean this kind of backwards scenes order works fantastic for the movie Memento, but that of course is partially about twists and revelations.
But yeah, because it's just a kinda weird thing to do, it would be a worthwhile kind of experiment.
I do agree though that there's little point in writing this for more characters and this had just the right length anyways.
Re: Irreversible
Posted: Mon Apr 28, 2014 1:46 pm
by d2r
Blasphemy wrote:I enjoyed this and actually made me think about how I may have experienced the game if I had approached it like that, that is if such a reverse version existed. I assume I probably wouldn't really have appreciated it much... I mean this kind of backwards scenes order works fantastic for the movie Memento, but that of course is partially about twists and revelations.
To an extent, I was poking fun at that fact - the narrator is written as an
extremely pretentious academic, and his interpretation of the game is intended to be somewhat forced. Not to say that the narrator's commentary is 100% bullshit, but it's supposed to be taken with a grain of salt.
As I mentioned to Oddball, the piece was intended as a self-satire in some respects. However, I also think Oddball made a good point when he said that that it simply comes across as "a work which tries to be deep but fails at it" - as opposed to the intended "a work about a man who tries too hard to be deep". I didn't make the distinction clear enough.
Still, I'm glad people are enjoying it. In the end, I think, that's what matters.