Katawa Shoujo Forums

My personal answer is that her last relationship was with Hisao. After his death, she had no more relationships of that kind. Heh heh. We don't know about her prior relationships, though.

brythain wrote:My personal answer is that her last relationship was with Hisao. After his death, she had no more relationships of that kind. Heh heh. We don't know about her prior relationships, though.

I see what you did there

I don't think we can really ever know this, but third year guy sounds about right.

The track captain. Naturally, this fell apart upon her discovering that:

A) She was being used as a cover for homosexuality.

B) Due to said homosexuality, she couldn't use sex as a substitute for real attachment.

Some person of which we may never know, and shouldn't care about.

Potato wrote:The track captain. Naturally, this fell apart upon her discovering that:

A) She was being used as a cover for homosexuality.

B) Due to said homosexuality, she couldn't use sex as a substitute for real attachment.

That doesn't make sense though. She said she broke up with the person because she couldn't let them in, not because she was being used as a lock on a closet door. It would totally defeat the purpose of even mentioning some other guy in-story, since the idea was to show where somebody else went wrong where Hisao must now go right.

Potato wrote:The track captain. Naturally, this fell apart upon her discovering that:

A) She was being used as a cover for homosexuality.

B) Due to said homosexuality, she couldn't use sex as a substitute for real attachment.

I doubt that someone who regularly has lemony gay sex in the track shed cares all that much about hiding their homosexuality.

FelOnyx wrote:

Potato wrote:The track captain. Naturally, this fell apart upon her discovering that:

A) She was being used as a cover for homosexuality.

B) Due to said homosexuality, she couldn't use sex as a substitute for real attachment.

I doubt that someone who regularly has lemony gay sex in the track shed cares all that much about hiding their homosexuality.

Is that anything like Lemony Snicket?

SpunkySix wrote:

FelOnyx wrote:

Potato wrote:The track captain. Naturally, this fell apart upon her discovering that:

A) She was being used as a cover for homosexuality.

B) Due to said homosexuality, she couldn't use sex as a substitute for real attachment.

I doubt that someone who regularly has lemony gay sex in the track shed cares all that much about hiding their homosexuality.

Is that anything like Lemony Snicket?

I hope not.

SpunkySix wrote:

FelOnyx wrote:

Potato wrote:The track captain. Naturally, this fell apart upon her discovering that:

A) She was being used as a cover for homosexuality.

B) Due to said homosexuality, she couldn't use sex as a substitute for real attachment.

I doubt that someone who regularly has lemony gay sex in the track shed cares all that much about hiding their homosexuality.

Is that anything like Lemony Snicket?

A Series of Unfortunate Anal Poundings.

SpunkySix wrote:Is that anything like Lemony Snicket?

Oh no. Can't unsee…

Now whenever I see something like "Can You Stand Up For Yourself?" I will think of "A Series of Unfortunate Questions".

SpunkySix wrote:

Potato wrote:The track captain. Naturally, this fell apart upon her discovering that:

A) She was being used as a cover for homosexuality.

B) Due to said homosexuality, she couldn't use sex as a substitute for real attachment.

That doesn't make sense though. She said she broke up with the person because she couldn't let them in, not because she was being used as a lock on a closet door. It would totally defeat the purpose of even mentioning some other guy in-story, since the idea was to show where somebody else went wrong where Hisao must now go right.

And yet, Hisao went 'wrong' in exactly the same way. Because, of course, wanting an actual meaningful connection is wrong. To Emi. Because she's dumb. Dumb as rocks.

And that's just it: Without the option of screwing him to keep him content, Tracky (canon name, dealwithit) would be all the more annoying with his insistence on being let in.

Potato wrote:

SpunkySix wrote:

Potato wrote:The track captain. Naturally, this fell apart upon her discovering that:

A) She was being used as a cover for homosexuality.

B) Due to said homosexuality, she couldn't use sex as a substitute for real attachment.

That doesn't make sense though. She said she broke up with the person because she couldn't let them in, not because she was being used as a lock on a closet door. It would totally defeat the purpose of even mentioning some other guy in-story, since the idea was to show where somebody else went wrong where Hisao must now go right.

And yet, Hisao went 'wrong' in exactly the same way. Because, of course, wanting an actual meaningful connection is wrong. To Emi. Because she's dumb. Dumb as rocks.

And that's just it: Without the option of screwing him to keep him content, Tracky (canon name, dealwithit) would be all the more annoying with his insistence on being let in.

No, he didn't. He went right by finding the right balance between giving her space but also being firm. The other guy couldn't do that. "Hey Hisao, don't be a gay guy because then Emi won't want to deal with you sexually and then she'll think you're dumb" doesn't make much sense as part of the route's theme.

Why are you so intensely convinced that Emi hates emotional relationships? Just because she has trouble with them, it doesn't follow that she's this dumb person who only desires sex. I feel like I keep explaining this and somewhere the explanation is being lost.

RandomPerson wrote:We were stumped

Booooooo

I'm astounded no one else jumped on this

I actually forgot I did that gag