Katawa Shoujo Forums

ShadeHaven wrote:

Xanatos wrote:
Insofar as I can tell, we're supposed to decide which girl will abuse their kid based on zero evidence and paper-thin baseless speculations. And since we're just disregarding the actual character of the girls, well, I say Lilly will torture her children to death.

And of course, Shizune will work her poor child to deaf.

Emi will run her kids ragged.

Rin will be untouched by their plight.

Hanako will leave her kids scarred for life.

Lily will fail to see the problem.

Moral of thread: it's completely unrealistic for the KS girls to grow up to become abusive due to their bitterness and horrible childhoods... even though most abusive parents become such due to their bitterness and horrible childhoods. Okay then.

Xanatos wrote:Hanako is vindictive and spiteful?

What game did you play again?

The same game you played, Xannykins. The game with the Hanako Ikezawa who said point blank she doesn't like people. The game with the Hanako Ikezawa who's an emotionally disturbed wreck. The game with the Hanako Ikezawa who says flat-out in her bad ending that Hisao and Lilly make her so blind with rage she fantasizes about murdering them. THAT game.

pandaphil - You are amazing.

ShadeHaven wrote:

Xanatos wrote:
Insofar as I can tell, we're supposed to decide which girl will abuse their kid based on zero evidence and paper-thin baseless speculations. And since we're just disregarding the actual character of the girls, well, I say Lilly will torture her children to death.

And of course, Shizune will work her poor child to deaf.

Ahhhh, I see what you did there!

Misha's kid would get diabetes from her mother's forced parfait diet.

@Katie: So because Hanako got really pissed off once, she's vindictive and spiteful? Shit, better inform...Everyone who has ever been angry and said something exaggeratedly negative...that they're actually vindictive spiteful monsters. Really, is that the justification you're sticking with here? Also note that she never says that anyway.

The moral of the thread is you can't ask which one will become abusive when there's no fucking evidence that any of them will do so. You might as well be polling us on which girl will become a coke whore.

And anyway, few of them had bad childhoods. Lilly's was fine. Emi's, fine. Rin's is never mentioned either way.

Shizune's had some communication failure but it never seems to have bothered her to the point that she'd heap abuse on her kids.

So we're left with only one. Hanako's was the only really bad childhood and it's entirely out of character for her to become abusive.

And the name is "Xanatos". Learn to read or get off the forum.

None of their childhoods (except Hanako, okay ) is really that bad, if their parents were abusive and their childhood ruined then they might become what you think will happen. There are worst examples of crappy adults with bad childhood and growing up.

You have a poor outlook in life.

pandaphil wrote: Emi will run her kids ragged.

Rin will be untouched by their plight.

Hanako will leave her kids scarred for life.

Lily will fail to see the problem.

I am gonna die of laughting now.

Shizune's is rather high on the emotional abuse. But, she's stubborn, Jigoro is stubborn, and I think generally people shake their heads at this father-daughter pair rather than cry abuse.

Quite honestly I can see Hanako developing more of a "Its you and me against the world" relationship with her child that would tend to bond them closer together.

At worst she might instill some timidity in her own children with her "Most people are no damn good." attitude.

Katie wrote:

Xanatos wrote:Hanako is vindictive and spiteful?

What game did you play again?

The same game you played, Xannykins. The game with the Hanako Ikezawa who said point blank she doesn't like people. The game with the Hanako Ikezawa who's an emotionally disturbed wreck. The game with the Hanako Ikezawa who says flat-out in her bad ending that Hisao and Lilly make her so blind with rage she fantasizes about murdering them. THAT game.

Let me stop you right there. She never says that. I even watched the Bad End to be sure. And Hanako would be the least of the girls to be abusive. "Sure, my life was a living hell because of emotional abuse. Let's inflict that on my child."

YZQ wrote:Shizune's is rather high on the emotional abuse. But, she's stubborn, Jigoro is stubborn, and I think generally people shake their heads at this father-daughter pair rather than cry abuse.

I think Shizune won't listen to her kid(s) and never told them what to do.

pandaphil wrote:

ShadeHaven wrote:

Xanatos wrote:
Insofar as I can tell, we're supposed to decide which girl will abuse their kid based on zero evidence and paper-thin baseless speculations. And since we're just disregarding the actual character of the girls, well, I say Lilly will torture her children to death.

And of course, Shizune will work her poor child to deaf.

Emi will run her kids ragged.

Rin will be untouched by their plight.

Hanako will leave her kids scarred for life.

Lily will fail to see the problem.

Go to second 32:

In the Bad End, Hanako did say that she hated Lily and Hisao. But, the tearful face right before she closes the door shouts to me that she doesn't mean what she said.

This thread might just last long with the puns......

pandaphil wrote: At worst she might instill some timidity in her own children with her "Most people are no damn good." attitude.

Maybe if Hisao went and had the bad ending, she might hardly recover and became a bit bitter. Still, implying she has children means that she found someone special like if Hisao went after her, she might've resolve her problems.

Hanako never said she thought about murdering Hisao and Lilly. She shouted that she hated them, but she feels bad about it almost immediately afterwards.

The winner of this poll, who happens to be absent on the list is:

Beta Hanako, due to the fact she becomes a mother way too early AND has serious issues that make her a danger to herself and others.

The game with the Hanako Ikezawa who says flat-out in her bad ending that Hisao and Lilly make her so blind with rage she fantasizes about murdering them. THAT game.

So you played a version of the game that you made up in your head and doesn't actually exist for anyone else.

Suddenly your posts make much more sense in that light.

Here we go again...

Emi - because she doesn't want people to become close to her = she'd treat her child like she treated Hisao.