Katawa Shoujo Forums

Examples of VNs that made good anime:
Clannad (Best anime ever. Period.)
Fate/Stay Night
Yosuga No Sora

It CAN be done. It HAS been done. But, yes, those are largely exceptions to the rule that an anime from a VN is a bad idea. Which is why I'm curious as to whether a KS anime would be good or not, and it would depend on what company made the anime.

max7238 wrote:Clannad (Best anime ever. Period.

Clannad is good, but not the best. It wouldn't even make it to my top 10.
Some people I know, like my cousin, have seen Clannad and afterwards they don't accept that other animes can be better. We watched another anime together, and I could see that he liked it a lot, but when I asked him, all he said was: "No! Clannad is so much better. "
Conclusion: Clannad is a brainwasher.

My top 10 would probably be (not in order):
• Kanon
• Toradora!
• Tsukuyomi Moon Phase
• Zero no Tsukaima
• Hanbun no Tsuki ga Noboru Sora
• School Rumble
• Asura Cryin'
• Gungrave
• Negima
• Angel Beats or Love Hina

I would love it, it could have 5 different series, one for each girl. Obviously it would be the good ending .

Not going to happen but there are worse things not going to happen :/.

OtakuNinja wrote:

max7238 wrote:Clannad (Best anime ever. Period.

Clannad is good, but not the best. It wouldn't even make it to my top 10.
Some people I know, like my cousin, have seen Clannad and afterwards they don't accept that other animes can be better. We watched another anime together, and I could see that he liked it a lot, but when I asked him, all he said was: "No! Clannad is so much better. "
Conclusion: Clannad is a brainwasher.

My top 10 would probably be (not in order):
• Kanon
• Toradora!
• Tsukuyomi Moon Phase
• Zero no Tsukaima
• Hanbun no Tsuki ga Noboru Sora
• School Rumble
• Asura Cryin'
• Gungrave
• Negima
• Angel Beats or Love Hina

Kanon? That's not how you spell Naruto...

Xanatos wrote:

OtakuNinja wrote: Clannad is good, but not the best. It wouldn't even make it to my top 10.
Some people I know, like my cousin, have seen Clannad and afterwards they don't accept that other animes can be better. We watched another anime together, and I could see that he liked it a lot, but when I asked him, all he said was: "No! Clannad is so much better. "
Conclusion: Clannad is a brainwasher.

My top 10 would probably be (not in order):
• Kanon
• Toradora!
• Tsukuyomi Moon Phase
• Zero no Tsukaima
• Hanbun no Tsuki ga Noboru Sora
• School Rumble
• Asura Cryin'
• Gungrave
• Negima
• Angel Beats or Love Hina

Kanon? That's not how you spell Naruto...

Correct.
I haven't watched Naruto, and I never will. It's part of the shonen-trio and thereby hate-material. I'm into shojo and seinen, with a few exceptions.

OtakuNinja wrote:Correct.
I haven't watched Naruto, and I never will. It's part of the shonen-trio and thereby hate-material. I'm into shojo and seinen, with a few exceptions.

No worries. I have, and it sucks.

*Raises hand*

I actually kinda like Naruto... Not as much as other manga, but it's far better than the other two of the shounen trio.

dwarduk wrote:*Raises hand*

I actually kinda like Naruto... Not as much as other manga, but it's far better than the other two of the shounen trio.

The only thing I like about Naruto is one of the songs; Keisei Gyakuten

OtakuNinja wrote:

dwarduk wrote:*Raises hand*

I actually kinda like Naruto... Not as much as other manga, but it's far better than the other two of the shounen trio.

The only thing I like about Naruto is one of the songs; Keisei Gyakuten

Naruto actually has some of the best intro music of the 3

ive stopped following them though. its pretty clear that none of the authors really like working on it anymore and only do so due to cashcow franchise and contract.

ironically even though i stopped following it, Naruto got me into listening to japanese music. or at least more anime themes like the FLCL theme and .hack//sign theme.

Money ruin everything. Let the story lay on your mind.
And since everyone else is saying that, KS anime it's not gonna happen.

bragança wrote:Money ruin everything.

That's why KS is so successful

In the spirit of KS's origin story, we should make the KS anime ourselves, each of us taking on 15 seconds of animation and sound and then splicing them together.

It worked for the Star Wars fanbase.

WorldlyWiseman wrote:In the spirit of KS's origin story, we should make the KS anime ourselves, each of us taking on 15 seconds of animation and sound and then splicing them together.

It worked for the Star Wars fanbase.

Oh god no...

Xanatos wrote:

OtakuNinja wrote:Correct.
I haven't watched Naruto, and I never will. It's part of the shonen-trio and thereby hate-material. I'm into shojo and seinen, with a few exceptions.

No worries. I have, and it sucks.

omg, Naruto...
don't get me started, I'm so fucking mad with kishimoto that I just want to smack him in the head
stupid idiot! finish it already! I DON'T GIVE A SHIT ABOUT THE HACHIBI'S PAST OR ABOUT FUCKING TOBI, CAUSE EVERYBODY FUCKING KNOWS WHO TOBI IS !!!

....

anyway, School Rumble is one of my favs, it's pretty close to the manga storyline and well, if you want to finish it and find out more about the Harima-Eri relationship the you better read the "San Gakki" part of the anime that was never made

Akros wrote:anyway, School Rumble is one of my favs, it's pretty close to the manga storyline and well, if you want to finish it and find out more about the Harima-Eri relationship the you better read the "San Gakki" part of the anime that was never made

I have. I also bought volume 1-6, and I'm going to buy the rest too (Although they're very expensive and hard to find ). I've been waiting for the complete anime collection since January. It was supposed to be a birthday gift from my grandparents, but it was sold out here in Sweden*, and probably in the US too. They said it would be available in February, but it's already August and nothing has happened.

*There is only one store in Sweden that sells imported anime and manga. Some old stuff (Dragonball, One Piece and Love Hina) can be bought in local book stores, but that's only because it's been translated to Swedish by a guy who's recently lost his translator job due to the "manga case".