Katawa Shoujo Forums

If you look at KS as not a eroge. Then most of them are wonderful done. Have a nice tact to the, fitting the mood.
Only feel like sizunes first was a bit sloppy done.

If you look at KS as a eroge. Then they are more or less terible.. Dont exactly read eroges for the realism that this game have in its h-scens.

I thought they were all very well done and were actually a good vehicle for the story in some of the routes Hanako's and Rin's first and even in the routes where they weren't they were tastefully done and showed how usually the two partners where first timers and really didn't know what they were doing, which made them more sweet rather than sexy.

(that being said i found I couldn't fap to any of them, I was too emotionally invested in finding out what happened next)

Last man sitting wrote:I thought they were all very well done and were actually a good vehicle for the story in some of the routes Hanako's and Rin's first and even in the routes where they weren't they were tastefully done and showed how usually the two partners where first timers and really didn't know what they were doing, which made them more sweet rather than sexy.

(that being said i found I couldn't fap to any of them, I was too emotionally invested in finding out what happened next)

Yea, i was so focused and into the story that the sex scenes just was another part of it, and they really are another part of it, and that's a fact that i love

Hohohohoho.. I never had any problem with them, if you know what I mean..

However, I did feel like some of them were bit too short.. But I guess that's quite realistic anyways considering that to begin with, 5 of them were Hisao's first times.. I'd say that mostly they were well written too, won't go as far as to say that they were best I have seen, but they were really good and most of them fit the story really well..Even the Anal.

You guys are missing the fuck out. Who the fuck actually reads the ero scenes instead of partaking in delicious sensor melons and shrimp.

Last man sitting wrote:I thought they were all very well done and were actually a good vehicle for the story in some of the routes Hanako's and Rin's first and even in the routes where they weren't they were tastefully done and showed how usually the two partners where first timers and really didn't know what they were doing, which made them more sweet rather than sexy.

(that being said i found I couldn't fap to any of them, I was too emotionally invested in finding out what happened next)

True about the 'sweet rather than sexy', although I did think Shizune's second h-scene and some of Lilly's especially the blindfold scene, including the masturbation part were pretty damn arousing.

That's not to say all scenes were nice to watch. Hanako's and especially Misha's scenes were rather uncomfortable to watch, but that was exactly the point. Hisao even mentions it himself in Misha's scene, how wrong it felt.

chicunsu wrote:

Last man sitting wrote:I thought they were all very well done and were actually a good vehicle for the story in some of the routes Hanako's and Rin's first and even in the routes where they weren't they were tastefully done and showed how usually the two partners where first timers and really didn't know what they were doing, which made them more sweet rather than sexy.

(that being said i found I couldn't fap to any of them, I was too emotionally invested in finding out what happened next)

Yea, i was so focused and into the story that the sex scenes just was another part of it, and they really are another part of it, and that's a fact that i love

Count me third. I've done Lilly and Hanako's route so far, and I felt like they handled those kind of scenes perfectly. They're not just porno, they're emotional and tie into the story. Artistic, rather than pandering, precisely because they were bold enough to not always give us exactly what we wanted. Hanako's scene is the first ever adult scene to nearly bring me to tears, and Lilly's scenes were more heartwarming than erotic, to me.

i had no problem with any of them yet .... they were well done ( did all paths except Rin's ) .... idk what ppl want but the devs did a pefect job ... the are many free hentai sites out there ( goggle them if u want ) leave this beautiful masterpeice of a VN alone with the useless bicthing about what is wrong with the H scenes in KS ( ppl are never happy with the way things are )

I had this thought as well, during my first playthrough I considered toggling the H-content to off because I was so engrossed in the story and felt that the adult content would ruin it, but having played through three routes so far I feel it would almost be a disservice to turn off the Adult content, people have sex, it just makes sense to have these scenes in the game and if you skipped Hanako's I feel like you'd take away heavily from the end of the game itself.

Guest wrote:You guys are missing the fuck out. Who the fuck actually reads the ero scenes instead of partaking in delicious sensor melons and shrimp.

Bahaha. I disabled H-scenes for one scene just to see what would happen and I lolwut-ed. Why melons?
Edit: Ohhhhh.

anonomouse wrote:Did anyone else have trouble with how the erotic scenes were written into the plot. I didn't particularly enjoy most of them since they felt like they were only put in there to comply with eroge canon. It seemed like they were just put in to advance the plot most of the time. The only ones I felt were done properly were Rin's. The writing and the build up there made the scenes seem heavy; showing the tension between the characters, enhancing the story. Emi's were laughable, but i get that it was a joke, albeit necessary.

The writing just felt sloppy in compassion to the rest of the game. I wish the writers would have spent a little more time on them and did some better research.

Personally I would disagree with you - I felt the writing for the sex scenes was very tasteful and natural; romance is just as much about sex/love-making/whatever as it is about heartfelt feelings and such; and if anything, compliments each other as a whole if balanced together.

Ultimately, jsut like people in real life, everyone approaches sex and love differently, just as the Heroines do based on their personalities.

Harco wrote:

Last man sitting wrote:I thought they were all very well done and were actually a good vehicle for the story in some of the routes Hanako's and Rin's first and even in the routes where they weren't they were tastefully done and showed how usually the two partners where first timers and really didn't know what they were doing, which made them more sweet rather than sexy.

(that being said i found I couldn't fap to any of them, I was too emotionally invested in finding out what happened next)

True about the 'sweet rather than sexy', although I did think Shizune's second h-scene and some of Lilly's especially the blindfold scene, including the masturbation part were pretty damn arousing.

That's not to say all scenes were nice to watch. Hanako's and especially Misha's scenes were rather uncomfortable to watch, but that was exactly the point. Hisao even mentions it himself in Misha's scene, how wrong it felt.

I completely agree. Lilly's first H-scene was pretty sudden for me, but it felt like it added to the plot. Usually in a movie or otherwise it would be cut out, which is a bit jarring. The way they sex scenes just flowed with the rest of the story felt right, and I liked that they weren't the ultimate end-goal of the plot -- just a nice step to the meat and potatoes. Or watermelons and shrimp.

They were mostly tasteful.

Not sure why Hanako's scene was the only one with explicit penetration (cg) but all scenes were equivalent to a romance movie's softcore scenes. Nothing overtly ridiculous like having the chick lay on her neck/upper back while penetrating her from a standing position (feels really good though). There weren't any bj scenes that would have made the girls feel cheap. The dry humping reminded me when I was twelve before losing my virginity, so it felt very "real". Overall though, the scenes had a point and they were really made but most felt a lack of affection.

Not sure why Hanako's scene was the only one with explicit penetration

Im probably just reading into it - but when I think on it, I feel it was done that way to remind the reader just how astutely self-aware both Hisao and Hanako were during the act (I cant recall exactly the description, but i remember it being something like " Hanako's face was turned to me, but her eyes were aimed lower, to the area joining us".

eh, i thought they all had levels of affection - but the two with the least would by Shizao (damn already forgot her name heh, and Emi) and even then, there was a kind of affection, but either more mature - or simply casual~

Having completed all the routes, I have to say I felt like the H scenes were beautiful, tasteful art, and the writing carried the story on through it. I felt like I would have missed out if I had disabled them... Even Misha's scene was heartbreaking and sad, as was clearly intended.
That said... I really disliked Hanako's H scene. It was too graphic and 'porn' for my tastes... clearly from the previous comments I am a minority in this preference though.
What I like, what really does it for me, is seeing the tender emotional connection between the characters, and that can't happen when Hisao wasn't even on screen. Possibly the problem is that, as a female, I am not playing through Hisao's eyes, so the Hisao-eye-view of the scene felt wrong to me... I prefer there to be a pretty picture on screen of a pretty couple doing beautiful things.
That's probably why Lilly was my favorite, the tenderness of their interaction really got to me.