Page 2 of 3

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2015 1:13 am
by YZQ
SpunkySix wrote:
Liminaut wrote:Absolutely go through the bad ends. They are half the story and tell you a lot about the all the characters.
Unless we're talking about Emi... then it's very brief and tell you absolutely nothing about her that you didn't already know.

She's just like, kbai Hisao fek u m8-

Which, brilliantly enough, is kind of the point of that ending.
Well, she did that before, so....

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2015 1:36 am
by SpunkySix
YZQ wrote:
SpunkySix wrote:
Liminaut wrote:Absolutely go through the bad ends. They are half the story and tell you a lot about the all the characters.
Unless we're talking about Emi... then it's very brief and tell you absolutely nothing about her that you didn't already know.

She's just like, kbai Hisao fek u m8-

Which, brilliantly enough, is kind of the point of that ending.
Well, she did that before, so....
Exactly!

The point is that if you press her too much without showing understanding and flexibility, she brick walls just like everybody warned you and you don't get to find out anything else about her- she doesn't want you to. The it gets cut off forever, unless you go by a certain fantastic fanfic on here where they get back together later on in life due to two students getting them to go to the Shanghai together.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2015 1:38 am
by YZQ
Gotta PM me that fic's name. Love second chance fics, if done well.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2015 1:42 am
by SpunkySix
YZQ wrote:Gotta PM me that fic's name. Love second chance fics, if done well.
Silent Knights, by brythain:

http://ks.renai.us/viewtopic.php?f=52&t ... 77#p220477

It's not a PM because it's actually a pretty good follow up if TC wants to feel better after seeing that ending.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2015 2:05 am
by YZQ
Read the fic. Sometimes, when one asks, "Can I love again," the answer is "Yes, yes you can."

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2015 10:54 pm
by Liminaut
The thing I really like about Emi's route I in order to get Emi to accept someone else's assistance, Hisao has to accept assistance from someone else -- either Mutou or Misha.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:23 am
by SpunkySix
Liminaut wrote:The thing I really like about Emi's route I in order to get Emi to accept someone else's assistance, Hisao has to accept assistance from someone else -- either Mutou or Misha.
That is neat. Depending on the ending you get, you either lead by example, or end up being a total hypocrite.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 3:20 am
by Ryusashi
SpunkySix wrote:
Liminaut wrote:The thing I really like about Emi's route I in order to get Emi to accept someone else's assistance, Hisao has to accept assistance from someone else -- either Mutou or Misha.
That is neat. Depending on the ending you get, you either lead by example, or end up being a total hypocrite.
I like me some hypocrites.... but damn I actually didnt think of that. I always thought it was "I want to help so please let me and stop brick walling me.". Interesting.... im going to go dissect the routes again. Maybe I missed something else.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 3:26 am
by BMFJack
Ryusashi wrote:Maybe I missed something else.
There's no doubt you missed something else. Even if you play Katawa Shoujo to 100% completion from scratch hundreds of times over, there's bound to be some sentiment or another that escapes you.

That's the joy, though. To come back to something old and find something new hidden inside.

This is probably (read: definitely) bragging, but I actually had to go back and play through Katawa Shoujo again multiple times so I could see the bad/neutral endings. I got the good ending for every girl, first try. Cuz I'm a boss like that.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 9:27 am
by YZQ
It actually depends on your mood as you're playing. I just think of it as a really good story.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 9:23 pm
by Charmant
san1111 wrote:I created this topic because my first attempt at KS failed miserably and I got Hanako's bad ending. This was one of the most depressing experiences of my life, I couldn't think about anything else for quite some time and I have that 'dem feels' feeling even as I'm writing this. I also haver to mention that Hanako was/is by far my favourite character in the game (let's admit it, I loved her as much as a visual novel character can be loved).


The idea of watchig the bad endings came to my mind because went to YouTube a moment ago and a user whose KS videos I followed just finished the series and now he's recording the neutral/bad endings and I wanted to know if I wanted to see them.
Whether or not you want to see them, you should. And not via some guy's recording.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 10:10 pm
by BMFJack
Charmant wrote:Whether or not you want to see them, you should. And not via some guy's recording.
I think this is how it's been said best. There's something a bit more visceral about doing it yourself, rather than watching someone else do it. Especially because they usually have commentary. It's like watching a movie-theater bootleg of a new release; sure, you'll get the general idea. It wont be as good as if you'd been in that theater yourself, though.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2015 10:11 am
by YZQ
Agreed on the commentary part. If you can find a playthrough without commentary, it'll be better. (But, if that's the case, might as well play it yourself using the flowchart.)

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2015 10:43 am
by Mirage_GSM
I've never understood why anyone would watch a playthrough of KS on Youtube.

As far as I can tell there are three reasons to watch a playthrough:
1) You can't afford or don't want to pay for the game in question or you use the video as a demo before you buy the game.
KS is free and downloading it costs less bandwith than streaming the video, so no advantage there.

2) You lack the skills to play through the game.
Also not applicable for KS, since there are plenty of guides to get to any ending you like.

3) The commentator is funny.
YMMV on this, but frankly I have yet to find a KS video that I didn't abort two minutes in, because some idiot insists on reading out loud every line talking over the music and generally ruining the experience.

Okay, I just thought of 4) You're too lazy to hit the space bar every few seconds.
If that's the case I really can't help you.

Re: Do I want to see the bad/neutral endings?

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2015 7:10 pm
by YZQ
Well, for myself, even if I don't play all endings myself, I'll still read about them.