Optical Illusions

A forum for general discussion of the game: Open to all punters


Post Reply
User avatar
Flutterz
Posts: 230
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 2:40 am

Optical Illusions

Post by Flutterz »

So just last weekend I discovered Katawa Shoujo. Thankfully that Friday and Monday were also weekends due to easter, because I was so busy playing that I went to sleep later than I usually wake up. Needless to say I loved the game, 100%ed it, and the rest of the week was a sleepy blur. But all of that isn't really important. A little while ago I was browsing what I missed of SMBC and found this
http://www.smbc-comics.com/comics/20120412.gif
Instantly, that got me thinking, how WOULD you explain the idea of an optical illusion to, say, Lilly without making her think that sighted people are idiots? Do you know any auditory/tactile etc. illusions that could help?
Image
Completed VNs: VNDB
Currently Reading: ef- a fairy tale of the two
PikKirby
Posts: 50
Joined: Sun Mar 25, 2012 1:22 pm

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by PikKirby »

Auditory Illusions? Surrounding said fictional Lilly around a set of surround speakers and running some weird confusing full surround sound that keeps changing direction.
Tactile Illusions? Those cheap little high school "Haunted Houses" where they have bowls covered and you touch them. (I.E. Grapes for eyeballs, spaghetti for guts etc.)

I think auditory would be the closest bet, bats use "sonic" chirps and map their environment, I would think that a human using hearing would be similar. I would say playing around with sound is the closest thing you can relate to in terms of optical illusions.
Last edited by PikKirby on Sat Apr 14, 2012 3:10 am, edited 1 time in total.
ImageImageImageImageImage
User avatar
Alexbond45
Posts: 210
Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2012 1:08 am
Location: The United States of America

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Alexbond45 »

Optical Illusion

Is when you play a Trick on the Sight Sense.
B.Deese wrote:There are two types of people, those who are ignorant, and those who are stupid, ignorant people do it wrong and don't know it's wrong, stupid people do it wrong and know it's wrong. Don't be Stupid!
Marching Band starts back up soon. HOO-AH!
MY CODE:
1-Every Day is a New Day! 2-Never Give Up 3-Never stop being Positive 4-Marching Band FTW! 5-Be Nice to everyone.
User avatar
Mirrormn
Posts: 431
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2012 12:49 am

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Mirrormn »

Well, in the first place, the example given in the comic is barely even an optical illusion:
Image
It's just a picture of a vase whose contours are specifically designed to look like the silhouettes of two faces. Once you understand that, it's not difficult at all to see the image either way, or in both ways at the same time.

In my opinion, something like this is a much better example of an optical illusion. The eye is tricked into seeing the box in a certain way, and even if you understand the mechanics of the illusion and know you're being tricked, it's still quite difficult to interpret the object the way it really exists.

That being said, there is one auditory phenomenon I know of that I think is very analogous to this concept of optical illusions: Shephard tones. The example on that page of the Shephard-Risset glissando will cause you to hear a note that constantly descends and yet eventually ends up at the exact same pitch as it started.

As for tactile illusions, I don't know of any really amazing ones (probably because it's not possible to share tactile illusion over the Internet), but the sense of touch is not infallible either, and can easily be tricked. For example, the common practice of putting a bowl of spaghetti in a darkened room in a haunted house and telling your victims that it is a bowl of human brain tissue. Or, the way heat can often be misinterpreted as the pain of a sharp object, or vice-versa.
Katawa Shoujo OST Transcriptions and Arrangements: Consolidated list

Katawa Shoujo Music Index and Table of Contents

Game completion: 100% several times over
Favorite route: Rin
Insights on Rin | Insights on Shizune
User avatar
Murkglow
Posts: 47
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 12:13 pm

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Murkglow »

I personally don't think you'd really need to be all that elaborate or go out of your way to provide sound/touch illusions. Lilly is a smart young woman who, while not having first hand experience with it, understands the concept of sight (as well as it is possible for her to at any rate). Simply explaining how the image looks vs how the reality of the situation is should be enough for her to understand it. For example telling her that you know the image is simply a picture printed on a piece of paper but when looked at it can appear like a three dimensional object seems like it would would be enough to me. She can understand the concept of something being other then what one might first have thought it to be.
Favorite Routes:
Rin > Emi > Hanako > Shizune > Lilly
User avatar
Flutterz
Posts: 230
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 2:40 am

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Flutterz »

Mirrormn wrote:Well, in the first place, the example given in the comic is barely even an optical illusion:
Image
It's just a picture of a vase whose contours are specifically designed to look like the silhouettes of two faces. Once you understand that, it's not difficult at all to see the image either way, or in both ways at the same time.

In my opinion, something like this is a much better example of an optical illusion. The eye is tricked into seeing the box in a certain way, and even if you understand the mechanics of the illusion and know you're being tricked, it's still quite difficult to interpret the object the way it really exists.

That being said, there is one auditory phenomenon I know of that I think is very analogous to this concept of optical illusions: Shephard tones. The example on that page of the Shephard-Risset glissando will cause you to hear a note that constantly descends and yet eventually ends up at the exact same pitch as it started.

As for tactile illusions, I don't know of any really amazing ones (probably because it's not possible to share tactile illusion over the Internet), but the sense of touch is not infallible either, and can easily be tricked. For example, the common practice of putting a bowl of spaghetti in a darkened room in a haunted house and telling your victims that it is a bowl of human brain tissue. Or, the way heat can often be misinterpreted as the pain of a sharp object, or vice-versa.
I agree that that is one of the weakest illusions, but it is also one of the simplest and well-known ones, which is why it was used in that comic.

Hmm, those Shepard tones would probably be the best in terms of explaining illusions. Although our sense of touch is fallible, I'm not sure if you can use it very well to tell the spaghetti from the brain one you've had a good touch of it. And being able to see where you were fooled is a big part of illusion as far as I'm concerned.

Murkglow wrote:I personally don't think you'd really need to be all that elaborate or go out of your way to provide sound/touch illusions. Lilly is a smart young woman who, while not having first hand experience with it, understands the concept of sight (as well as it is possible for her to at any rate). Simply explaining how the image looks vs how the reality of the situation is should be enough for her to understand it. For example telling her that you know the image is simply a picture printed on a piece of paper but when looked at it can appear like a three dimensional object seems like it would would be enough to me. She can understand the concept of something being other then what one might first have thought it to be.
See, I'm not so sure that she can grasp sight at the level of fooling it. Sight is our most complicated sense, it transmits the most data, more accurately than the other senses, and faster. So fully understanding something on a higher level that anything you have ever experienced is nigh impossible. Like imagining that you do not exist.
Image
Completed VNs: VNDB
Currently Reading: ef- a fairy tale of the two
User avatar
Murkglow
Posts: 47
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 12:13 pm

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Murkglow »

Is it really "understanding something on a higher level"? She knows what a two dimensional picture is and knows what a three dimensional object is. She understands how vision works (again as well as she can) we even see that she is perfectly able to write out a note to hisao by herself (which surely requires at least a basic understanding of sight, images, and how they are perceived). She understands the concept of fooling/misleading a person (she enjoys doing it and has surely experienced hearing a sound or feeling an object that wasn't what she thought it was, whether that sound was a person altering the tone of their voice or whatever). Personally this sounds kinda condescending, that she wouldn't be able to understand because vision is just that awesome. Maybe I'm wrong, but I just can't believe that the concept of an optical illusion would be that difficult to grasp (even if she will obviously never experience it).
Favorite Routes:
Rin > Emi > Hanako > Shizune > Lilly
User avatar
Flutterz
Posts: 230
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 2:40 am

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Flutterz »

Murkglow wrote:Is it really "understanding something on a higher level"? She knows what a two dimensional picture is and knows what a three dimensional object is. She understands how vision works (again as well as she can) we even see that she is perfectly able to write out a note to hisao by herself (which surely requires at least a basic understanding of sight, images, and how they are perceived). She understands the concept of fooling/misleading a person (she enjoys doing it and has surely experienced hearing a sound or feeling an object that wasn't what she thought it was, whether that sound was a person altering the tone of their voice or whatever). Personally this sounds kinda condescending, that she wouldn't be able to understand because vision is just that awesome. Maybe I'm wrong, but I just can't believe that the concept of an optical illusion would be that difficult to grasp (even if she will obviously never experience it).
Hmm, yeah, I suppose you're right. I guess I lauded sight a bit too much. Would have been interesting to ask a blind person about it though :)
Image
Completed VNs: VNDB
Currently Reading: ef- a fairy tale of the two
User avatar
Sin of my sins
Posts: 82
Joined: Fri Mar 16, 2012 3:15 pm
Location: Finland

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Sin of my sins »

PikKirby wrote: I think auditory would be the closest bet, bats use "sonic" chirps and map their environment, I would think that a human using hearing would be similar. I would say playing around with sound is the closest thing you can relate to in terms of optical illusions.
This. I think the best way to help a blind person see the point would be giving an example that has relevance to him/her.
User avatar
WorldlyWiseman
Posts: 361
Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2012 7:19 pm

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by WorldlyWiseman »

It's probably less of a problem of her not intellectually understanding sight and more a problem of Hisao being articulate enough to explain it sensibly.
Hanako's favorite joke is The Aristocrats, but she never tells it because Lilly finds it really offensive. Instead, she practices her delivery in front of a mirror when she's alone. It's the only time she never stammers.
GIRakaCHEEZER
Posts: 69
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2012 8:42 pm

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by GIRakaCHEEZER »

I think the best way to explain an optical illusion to Lilly is to give her a tactile illusion:

http://mindbluff.com/lips.htm
http://mindbluff.com/nose.htm

Also here's more Optical Illusions for those that are interested:
Music for a game that I am sort of working on:
Moustache Riders - Ignition
This seems to be sort of common in sigs here so...
Rin = Kenji > Hanako > Emi > Lilly > Shizune
Guest

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Guest »

Easy, I would just say it's like listening to two songs at the same time. And your "view" changes based on which song you focus on more. I think that's a good comparison.
User avatar
Flutterz
Posts: 230
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 2:40 am

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Flutterz »

GIRakaCHEEZER wrote:I think the best way to explain an optical illusion to Lilly is to give her a tactile illusion:

http://mindbluff.com/lips.htm
http://mindbluff.com/nose.htm

Also here's more Optical Illusions for those that are interested:
Those first 2 are pretty good, although I don't think it's really related to phantom limb pain, your body is used to the outsides of two fingers being on opposite sides, so when both sides touch a single object your body thinks there are 2 objects.

And those optical illusions are... err... interesting. Up to the 3rd one I thought I was missing something.
Image
Completed VNs: VNDB
Currently Reading: ef- a fairy tale of the two
User avatar
Flutterz
Posts: 230
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 2:40 am

Re: Optical Illusions

Post by Flutterz »

Guest wrote:Easy, I would just say it's like listening to two songs at the same time. And your "view" changes based on which song you focus on more. I think that's a good comparison.
Huh, that's actually really good, and really simple!

That awkward moment when you think you should have thought of something first :P
Image
Completed VNs: VNDB
Currently Reading: ef- a fairy tale of the two
Post Reply